Hard

Design an Evaluation Platform for AI Agents System Design Interview

Design datasets, trace grading, simulation, regression detection, and release gates for non-deterministic tool-using agents.

1. Problem Statement

Design an evaluation platform that decides whether a new model, prompt, tool, or orchestration change is safe to release for a coding and research agent.

2. Architecture Discussion Map

Use this as one discussion aid, not a single correct answer. Your design should follow from the requirements, scale, and trade-offs you establish.

Rendering architecture diagram...
Mermaid Source (For AI Bots)
graph LR
    A["Design an Evaluation Platform for AI Agents"]
    A --> F1["Eval taxonomy, datasets, and task environments"]
    A --> F2["Trace collection and structured graders"]
    A --> F3["Non-determinism, statistical power, and infrastructure noise"]
    A --> F4["Safety/adversarial cases and human calibration"]
    A --> F5["CI release gates, observability, and feedback loops"]

3. Key Focus Areas

  • 1
    Eval taxonomy, datasets, and task environments
  • 2
    Trace collection and structured graders
  • 3
    Non-determinism, statistical power, and infrastructure noise
  • 4
    Safety/adversarial cases and human calibration
  • 5
    CI release gates, observability, and feedback loops

4. What Strong Candidates Should Demonstrate

  • Evaluate complete workflows rather than only final text.
  • Control non-determinism, infrastructure noise, and grader bias.
  • Turn production failures into repeatable datasets and release criteria.

Evaluation Guide

This is an evaluation framework, not a single model answer. Strong designs may make different choices when their assumptions and trade-offs are explicit.

What and how to measure

25%

Senior signals

  • Defines task success, tool selection, policy compliance, recovery, cost, latency, and final-answer quality.
  • Separates offline benchmarks, simulations, canaries, and production monitoring.

Trace and grader architecture

25%

Senior signals

  • Captures model calls, tool calls, handoffs, guardrails, environment state, and artifacts.
  • Uses deterministic checks where possible and calibrated model/human graders where necessary.

Experimental rigor

30%

Senior signals

  • Runs repeated trials, confidence intervals, stratification, paired comparisons, and environment controls.
  • Detects benchmark contamination, flaky tasks, grader drift, and infrastructure noise.

Release and learning loop

20%

Senior signals

  • Defines severity-weighted gates, rollback, shadow/canary traffic, and failure triage.
  • Converts production incidents and user feedback into versioned regression datasets.

Trade-offs to articulate

  • Realism versus repeatability.
  • Human judgment quality versus evaluation cost.
  • Strict gates versus iteration speed.

Practice follow-up questions

  1. 1.Success rate moves from 72% to 75%. Is that enough to ship?
  2. 2.The same model scores differently on two sandbox images. How do you investigate?

Want interactive feedback?

Practice drawing this system component-by-component on a live whiteboard while the interviewer probes at your target level.

Start Interview

Core Concepts

Agent EvalsTrace GradingDatasetsSimulationRelease Gates